Two men accused of the 2023 murders of Canadian eco-resort owners Daniel Langlois and Dominique Marchand have pleaded not guilty during a High Court arraignment in Roseau, marking a significant step in one of Dominica’s most closely watched criminal cases.
Jonathan Scott Lehrer and Robert Thomas Snyder Jr. appeared before Justice Sejilla McDowall on Tuesday, April 14, 2026, where the indictment was formally read. Both men denied the charges, which allege that the killings occurred between November 29 and December 2, 2023, at Bois Cotlette in Soufrière.
The victims, who were associated with the Coulibri Ridge eco-resort, were reported missing before their bodies were later discovered in a burned vehicle near Gallion, adding to the seriousness and public concern surrounding the case.
During the proceedings, defense attorneys raised procedural concerns, particularly regarding access to their clients. Attorney Tiyani Behanzin indicated that an application alleging abuse of process would be filed, citing difficulties in meeting and communicating with the accused while they remain on remand.
In response, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions rejected claims of procedural irregularities. The prosecution maintained that all legal requirements were met, noting that the indictment was filed on March 26, 2026, and served to the accused on April 7, within the timeframe set out under criminal procedure rules.
Justice McDowall ruled that the arraignment could proceed, finding that the rules governing service and timing had been properly followed. The court also outlined a structured timeline for the next phase of the case.
Defense counsel has until April 17 to file affidavits and supporting documents related to the abuse of process claim. The prosecution is expected to respond by April 24, with both sides scheduled to submit written arguments by April 29. A hearing on the matter is set for May 1, with a ruling expected on May 4.
Both men remain in custody at the Dominica State Prison as the case continues. The proceedings are expected to address preliminary legal challenges before moving toward a full trial, as public interest in the outcome remains high.
This article is copyright © 2026 DOM767