Dominica’s 2030 Cruise Tourism Goal: Ambition or Illusion?

In recent years, the government of Dominica has announced a bold tourism goal: reaching 1 million cruise passengers annually by the year 2030. The target has been presented as a transformative strategy to stimulate the island’s economy, expand infrastructure, and solidify its brand as the “Nature Island of the Caribbean.” Minister for Tourism Denise Charles states this goal is attainable through sustained marketing, stronger partnerships with cruise lines, and the ongoing development of ports and related tourism services.

However, critics argue that this figure is politically driven, disconnected from logistical and financial realities, and lacking the necessary groundwork. Many believe the current trajectory of infrastructure investment, marketing capabilities, and service quality cannot realistically achieve a threefold increase in cruise arrivals within six years. This commentary explores both perspectives, using historical data, regional comparisons, passenger sentiment, and economic impact to offer a grounded view of what it will take to meet this milestone.

Historical Dominance and Sudden Decline

Between 2003 and 2010, Dominica outperformed now-dominant competitors like St. Kitts. In 2003, Dominica welcomed 77,000 cruise passengers versus St. Kitts’ 46,000. By 2004, Dominica surged to 383,000, while St. Kitts saw 254,000. Over a seven-year stretch from 2004 to 2010, Dominica averaged 404,000 cruise visitors annually, while St. Kitts averaged 327,000.

In 2010, Dominica registered 518,000 cruise passengers, its highest figure on record and slightly ahead of St. Kitts’ 516,000. These years were a golden era for the country’s cruise tourism sector.

However, this momentum did not last. Between 2011 and 2016, Dominica’s average dropped to 281,000, a decline of nearly 30%. By comparison, St. Kitts began to surge ahead, investing heavily in cruise infrastructure and branding itself as a premium port of call. Hurricanes, infrastructural stagnation, and missed marketing opportunities set Dominica back. In 2022, following the COVID-19 pandemic, Dominica recorded 180,000 arrivals, while St. Kitts jumped to 484,000. In 2023, Dominica improved to 314,000, but St. Kitts soared to 774,000, bringing the expanding disparity into focus.

These comparative trends matter because they demonstrate how targeted, strategic investments yield measurable dividends in cruise growth. St. Kitts constructed two cruise piers, implemented structured excursion models, and worked closely with cruise lines to enhance the visitor experience. Despite branding itself as an eco-tourism destination, Dominica did not modernise fast enough to keep pace.

Economic Impact: The Numbers Speak

The Florida-Caribbean Cruise Association (FCCA) revealed that in the 2023-2024 cruise year, Dominica earned US $20.9 million from direct cruise-related spending. Comparatively, St. Kitts generated US $113.1 million — more than five times Dominica’s intake.

Employment in the cruise sector also reveals glaring disparities. In 2023, Dominica’s cruise sector supported 497 jobs, with a total wage bill of US $4.2 million. St. Kitts supported 1,679 jobs, with wages totalling US$ $19.6 million. These figures reflect not just the volume of cruise calls, but the quality of on-island experiences that encourage passengers to spend money locally.

Moreover, local vendors, tour operators, restaurants, and transport providers in St. Kitts benefit from structured excursion systems, dedicated tourism police, and organised terminals. Dominica, by contrast, has struggled with inconsistent tour quality, poor signage, and overcrowding at popular natural sites.

Another key issue is revenue retention. Much of the money from cruise visits can leak offshore unless ports, tour operators, and services are locally owned. Dominica must prioritise local entrepreneurship, reduce dependency on foreign cruise agents who dominate booking pipelines, and retain commissions.

Stay-Over Visitors: The Overlooked Sector

While cruise arrivals garner headlines, stay-over tourism is often more economically impactful. Stay-over visitors spend more, stay longer, and engage more deeply with the economy. Yet, Dominica has struggled to grow this segment. From 2004 onward, Dominica has lost an average of 12,000 stay-over visitors per year, currently averaging about 70,000 annually.

This sharply contrasts with countries like Antigua and Barbuda, which consistently average over 250,000 yearly stay-over visitors. Dominica once ambitiously projected 500,000 stay-over visitors by 2020, but this goal has been quietly shelved.

Even with the advent of new flight routes like the United Airlines direct service from Miami, carrying a weekly full Boeing 737-700 would contribute just 6,552 passengers annually. At this rate, Dominica would still need years of sustained growth and major airlift investments to reach even half of Antigua’s annual total.

Stay-over visitor growth also hinges on quality accommodation, reliable international access, and high-value experiences such as spas, hiking lodges, culinary tours, and immersive culture. Dominica has an opportunity to lead in this area, but lacks scale and coordinated promotion.

Cruise Passenger Sentiment: Low Likelihood of Return

Perhaps the most critical issue facing Dominica’s cruise tourism ambitions is the low passenger return rate. According to a recent FCCA survey of cruise passengers in 33 Caribbean destinations, Dominica ranked 30th when respondents were asked, “How likely are you to return for a stay-over visit?”

This is damning. While visitors often enjoy Dominica’s lush rainforests and waterfalls, many leave feeling there’s a lack of amenities, shopping options, reliable transportation, and high-quality service experiences. This inhibits repeat visitation, crucial to converting cruise traffic into longer-term tourism benefits.

It also reflects a disconnect between what cruise passengers want and what Dominica currently offers. Other countries have integrated shopping villages, culinary experiences, and beach lounges tailored for cruise guests. Dominica offers raw beauty, but few curated, upscale options.

Infrastructure and Carrying Capacity

The Roseau Cruise Ship Berth cannot accommodate the world’s largest cruise liners. While smaller vessels still call on Dominica, the industry is increasingly dominated by mega-ships carrying over 5,000 passengers. Dominica is limited in the types and frequency of ships it can attract without expanded berths.

Furthermore, ground infrastructure, such as road access to sites, visitor centres, and restroom facilities, remains limited. Small independent vans dominate tourism transportation without coordination or regulation. Bottlenecks, subpar customer service, and low excursion variety contribute to poor visitor feedback.

Environmental degradation is also a risk. During peak ship visits, rivers, hot springs, and national parks are under pressure. Without sustainable visitor limits, Dominica may suffer the destruction of its brand and natural purity.

Is the Goal Achievable? Both Sides Speak

Proponents of the goal argue that Dominica is simply catching up. They note that the goal is feasible with continued investment in port development, branding efforts, and airline partnerships. New hotel developments, plans for cruise village facilities, and partnerships with Royal Caribbean and Carnival are cited as evidence of forward momentum.

Critics, however, call the 1 million figure overly ambitious. They cite past failed projections — like the 500,000 stay-over vision — and note that even at 300,000 passengers today, Dominica’s infrastructure already shows signs of strain. They argue that such goals are more political than practical without measurable year-over-year targets and independent evaluation.

They also highlight the risk of focusing too narrowly on cruise traffic while ignoring the diversification and resilience of other tourism industries. Overreliance on the cruise industry can leave the country vulnerable to shocks like natural disasters or global health events. Building cruise goals without reinforcing airlift, hotels, workforce development, and product quality is a half-strategy.

Where Do We Go from Here?

If Dominica is serious about its 2030 goal, it must shift from rhetoric to detailed execution. This includes:

• Port Expansion: Upgrading Roseau berth to accommodate larger ships and building new terminals.
• Excursion Innovation: Creating new, diverse shore experiences that appeal to adventure-seekers and leisure travellers.
• Training and Certification: Developing hospitality training programs to raise service standards across vendors, guides, and transport operators.
• Environmental Management: Implementing visitor limits, protected area protocols, and sustainable tourism certifications.
• Marketing Intelligence: Using data-driven strategies to attract high-value travellers and convert cruise passengers to repeat visitors.
• Balanced Development: Reinforcing air access, accommodations, and stay-over incentives to avoid over-dependence on cruise ships.

A national cruise tourism strategy must be led by a task force that includes stakeholders from government, private enterprise, civil society, and environmental watchdogs. Transparency, accountability, and clear reporting must be part of the process.

This goal should be broken into benchmarks: 400,000 by 2025, 600,000 by 2027, 800,000 by 2028, and a final stretch to 1 million in 2030. Without such incremental targets, the number risks being symbolic rather than strategic.

Achieving 1 million cruise passengers is possible, but it is not inevitable. Without a roadmap, Dominica risks repeating past cycles of overpromising and underdelivering. A serious strategy demands realism, evidence, and measurable commitment.

This article is copyright © 2025 DOM767